Carstar
The total investment to open a Carstar franchise ranges from $150,000 to $2.5M. The initial franchise fee is $20,000. Ongoing royalties are 5% plus a 2% advertising fee.
What is the Carstar franchise?
Carstar entered the collision repair industry in 1989, when Lirel Holt, a Kansas City collision repair company owner, saw how fragmented the sector was and created a network for independent shop owners. His model brought operators under one brand, with shared professional standards, common repair practices, group purchasing power, and operational support. The first location, Wicklunds CARSTAR, opened in Liberty, Missouri, that year. In 1994, Holt partnered with Sam Mercanti to bring Carstar to Canada. Mercanti became the master franchisor for the Canadian market, marking Carstar’s first international expansion. The company is now headquartered in Charlotte, North Carolina, and operates in the United States and Canada. PeerSense records 54 total units and 98 franchised units, while web research reports more than 446 units as of January 2024. Other sources report more than 750 locations across the United States and Canada and nearly 800 centers throughout North America. Carstar reached 600 North American locations in 2018 and exceeded 670 locations by July 2019. Figures from 2018 listed 311 United States franchises and 292 outside the country. The 2019 Franchise Disclosure Document reported 328 franchised locations in the United States. By June 2020, the network included approximately 385 United States stores and another 315 in Canada. Carstar Automotive Inc. became part of Driven Brands in December 2015, placing it alongside Maaco, Meineke, and Take 5 Oil Change. General automotive repair, including collision repair, is a multi billion dollar annual market supported by the growing number of vehicles and the ongoing need to repair accident damage. A buyer evaluating Carstar is therefore considering a brand with roots dating to 1989, an operating model developed over decades, and corporate backing from a large automotive franchise organization. PeerSense provides independent research for buyers considering the investment and does not act as a lender.
General automotive repair, including collision services, serves a large and durable North American market. Hundreds of millions of vehicles operate across the continent, creating demand for accident repairs, routine maintenance, and specialized services. The North American automotive repair market is valued in the hundreds of billions of dollars annually and has experienced steady growth. An aging vehicle parc supports repair demand because older vehicles generally need more frequent and extensive work. Modern vehicles also require specialized capabilities because they include advanced driver assistance systems, sophisticated sensors, and specialized materials. Independent shops without the right equipment or training may be unable to complete those repairs adequately, directing more work toward professionally equipped and certified networks such as Carstar, which invest in diagnostic and repair technology. Remote work may reduce commuting for some people, but it does not remove accidents or the need for collision services. The growing number of vehicles on the road supports continuing demand, while expanding ecommerce and larger delivery fleets increase vehicle use and the likelihood of incidents requiring professional repairs. Carstar supports franchisees pursuing original equipment manufacturer certifications and benefits from the industry’s increased attention to vehicle safety. The sector is also consolidating. Independent operators are increasingly giving way to larger networks that can provide consistent quality, maintain stronger insurance relationships, and obtain economies of scale. Insurance company preferences for network shops and the high cost of advanced diagnostic and repair equipment create barriers for new independent competitors. These conditions place Carstar within an essential repair category that is less dependent on short lived consumer trends or favorable economic conditions.
Carstar’s initial franchise fee is listed as $20,000 in the provided database. Web research gives a broader range of $10,000 to $20,000, while some reports cite $14,995 to $40,000. Differences may reflect market territory, conversion situations, or the scope of the initial agreement. New franchisees also pay a required integration fee of $10,000 for connection to Carstar systems and processes. Reported total investment figures vary with the type of facility, property costs, leasehold improvements, and equipment needs. One source reports a cost to get in from $23,500 to $165,300, which may reflect converting an existing shop or purchasing selected assets. Estimates for a full build out or substantial renovation range from $298,200 to $804,300 and from $283,700 to $829,800. These totals can include facility acquisition or leasehold improvements, furniture and fixtures, collision repair equipment, computer hardware and software, training for key personnel, opening inventory of parts and supplies, interior and exterior signs, and working capital for the first three months. The stated additional funds for those first three months range from $10,000 to $84,000. A candidate must have at least $500,000 in net worth. Reported liquid capital requirements range from $200,000 to $300,000, while another report gives a range of $100,000 to $250,000. This places Carstar in the mid to premium range of franchise investments and makes it more suitable for experienced owners with substantial available capital. One source instead reports a possible charge of up to $3.5K per month, potentially for very high volume centers. These charges support brand promotion, research and development, and franchise support. Driven Brands adds purchasing power, operating efficiencies, and access to automotive expertise. The available information does not detail SBA eligibility or veteran incentives. The financial requirements indicate that careful planning and potentially outside financing may be necessary.
A Carstar center manages a full collision repair workflow, beginning with vehicle intake and damage assessment, followed by repair work, painting, final inspection, and delivery. The operation depends on customer service, technical skill, and efficient workflow management to control cycle times and increase throughput. Staffing generally includes certified technicians who can work on modern vehicle systems, estimators who assess damage and negotiate with insurance companies, customer service representatives, and administrative staff. The available information does not specify a labor model, but the emphasis on continuing training and original equipment manufacturer certifications points to a workforce that must maintain current technical skills and quality standards. Carstar provides training and support intended to address the technical and operating demands of collision repair. Initial training includes classroom instruction and on the job instruction. It starts before the location opens and continues during the franchise agreement. One stated program includes 16 hours of classroom training and 24 to 50 hours of hands on training. Another source specifies 32 hours of practical application. This training is intended to prepare franchisees and key personnel to operate their centers and follow the brand’s procedures.
Loan Activity Score
60/100
SBA Default Rate
3.2%
Active Lenders
76
According to its Franchise Disclosure Document or public business records, Carstar has 102 locations, all owned by franchisees. Public SBA loan records show 76 lenders made 124 loans to franchisees of Carstar. PeerSense calculates Carstar's score as 60 out of 100, using public SBA loan performance and recent lending activity. Cost figures are based on the 2025 Franchise Disclosure Document. To correct a figure, email the current FDD and the differing item numbers to info@peersense.com, and this page will be updated.
Franchising since 1989 · 102 locations
$150,000 to $2.5M
$20,000
102
102 franchised
Proprietary PeerSense metric
ModerateDistinct lenders in public SBA records for Carstar
124
Total SBA loans
$866K
Average loan size
Source: public SBA 7(a) and 504 loan records through December 31, 2025
Referral fee at closing
SBA Lending Activity for Carstar
Loan Activity Score Breakdown
Major Brand (100+ loans)
Are lenders increasingly or decreasingly funding this brand? Growing trends score highest.
Blended default rate (recent + all time) compared to NAICS sector peers.
Quality lenders actively backing this brand, with penalty for lender pullback.
FDD availability, Item 19 disclosure, and overall data completeness.
Geographic spread of SBA funded locations across states.
SBA Lending Performance
SBA Default Rate
3.2%
vs 10.7% peer avg
SBA Loans
124
Total Volume
$107.4M
Active Lenders
76
4 selective
States
27
vs. SBA Sector Average
SBA loan default rate vs. all franchises in the same NAICS sector, not limited to direct competitors
Key Highlights
Franchise Financing Resources
Data Insights
Key performance metrics for Carstar based on SBA lending data
SBA Default Rate
3.2%
7.5% below peer avg
SBA Loan Volume
124 loans
Across 76 lenders
Lender Diversity
76 lenders
Avg 1.6 loans per lender
Investment Tier
Premium investment
$150,000 to $2,480,000 total
Carstar: Deep SBA Data
Brand specific metrics derived directly from SBA 7(a) approval records: peak lending year, leading state, average loan size, and lender concentration. PeerSense computes these per brand so capital advisors and prospective franchisees can benchmark this opportunity against the rest of the franchise universe.
Peak SBA Year
2021
16 approvals. The best year on record for Carstar.
Top SBA State
California
12 SBA financed Carstar locations, the densest operator footprint.
Average Loan Size
$866K
Median $780K. Use as a sizing anchor when modeling your own Carstar unit.
Lender Concentration
17.7%
Highly Diversified
Share of Carstar approvals captured by the top 3 SBA lenders.
Carstar's SBA lending pipeline peaked in 2021 (16 approvals). The last five fiscal years account for 36% of cumulative volume ($56M approved). Operator density is highest in California with 12 SBA financed locations. Average funded ticket sits at $866K, with the median at $780K. Lender mix is highly diversified: the top three SBA lenders account for 17.7% of approvals. Borrowers have leverage to shop multiple credit boxes.
Payment Estimator
Estimated Monthly Payment
$1,553
Principal & Interest only
Indicative only, as of November 1, 2026. Not a quote, commitment or offer of credit. Final pricing, leverage and terms are determined by the lender at underwriting, after full transaction materials are reviewed. PeerSense sources the file. The lender sets pricing. What these terms mean.
Locations
Carstar, unit breakdown
Explore Funding for Carstar
Our business financing consultants help connect you with the right lending partners. Referral fee paid at closing.
Or get an instant analysis
Scan Your Deal Instantly4 FDDs Available for Carstar
Review franchise fees, investment ranges, royalties, Item 19 financial data, and year over year trends. Request complimentary access through your PeerSense funding advisor.
Page Review
Reviewed by Edward L. Freeman, Founder and Managing Director, PeerSense
- PeerSense is a capital advisory firm that places commercial financing with direct capital sources; the capital source sets final terms.
- Edward L. Freeman founded PeerSense in January 2020.
- He is a Registered Franchise Consultant with Business Alliance, Inc., a credential issued in March 2022, and worked as a franchise consultant there from March 2022 to May 2023.
- His recorded experience includes a $22 million SBA construction loan, with about $16 million funded on the deal.
- In the 12 months through September 30, 2026, PeerSense tracked 912 publicly announced financings with a disclosed size of $361.32 billion. PeerSense Capital Data Report · Methodology page
Last reviewed LinkedIn profileAbout Edward Freeman